Menu of Settimi's Gelato in Sarasota, Florida, USA

Menu Overview

Settimi's Gelato, nestled in the vibrant heart of Sarasota at 367 B St Armands Cir, offers an authentic gelato experience that marries tradition with fresh, inventive flavors. As a food reviewer for Menufyy, I found the menu meticulously curated to satisfy both classic palates and adventurous taste buds. The array of gelatos here is nothing short of extraordinary, showcasing a stunning balance between creamy texture and intense flavor.

Among the standout selections, the Nocciola Gelato shines with its rich hazelnut essence that is both nutty and smooth. The Pistachio Gelato delivers a deep, natural flavor that recalls the finest Italian pistachios. The Caramel Waffle Cone Gelato is a delightful treat, incorporating sweet, buttery caramel that harmonizes superbly with the crisp waffle cone. For those seeking tropical vibrancy, the Pineapple Mango and Coconut Gelato offers a refreshing blend that is bright, fruity, and perfectly balanced, evoking the essence of a sun-kissed island.

The Tiramisu Gelato and Almond Joy Gelato are exemplary of Settimi's creativity, melding dessert favorite profiles into gelato form. The tiramisu brings the classic coffee, cocoa, and mascarpone notes to life with a smooth finish, while the Almond Joy Gelato combines coconut gelato with diced almonds and Belgian chocolate chips for an indulgent, textured delight.

One cannot overlook the Dulce de Leche Gelato and Sea Salt Caramel Gelato, both boasting luscious creamy bases and expertly crafted to balance sweetness with a subtle savory twist, enhancing the richness rather than overpowering it. The sugar-free options like the Sugar Free Cappuccino Gelato demonstrate Settimi's attention to inclusivity without sacrificing quality or taste.

For coffee enthusiasts, Settimi's Affogato & Latte selections offer an elegant complement to their gelato. The affogato expertly marries strong Italian ristretto with creamy gelato, creating a harmonious blend of bitter and sweet that awakens the senses.

The menu extends beyond gelato to include fresh fruit smoothies like the Emerald Delight and Booster Pineapple, bringing together vibrant fruits with coconut water for a refreshing counterbalance to the creaminess of the gelato offerings. This diversity highlights Settimi’s commitment to catering a broad spectrum of cravings and dietary needs.

The customer testimonials echo the exceptional quality and authenticity of Settimi's Gelato. From Fernando Alonso’s praise of the elite, Argentine-style ice cream experience blended with Italian charm, to Bethany Hale’s detailed appreciation of flavors like chocolate peanut butter and stracciatella, the consensus points to a consistently fresh and flavorful product. Patrons like Krzysztof Misterka compare it favorably to authentic Italian gelato, applauding the taste while noting a slightly premium price, but agreeing that the quality justifies it.

What truly resonates about Settimi's Gelato is its ability to provide a rich sensory journey—each spoonful melts with velvety smoothness, while the flavors unfold with precision, freshness, and depth. The meticulous craftsmanship is evident across every offering, from classic favorites to innovative blends. Whether enjoying a small cup on a sunny Sarasota afternoon or savoring a thermal container for take-home enjoyment, Settimi's Gelato elevates the humble ice cream moment to one of pure, indulgent pleasure.